Startup Consulting Services: What a Startup Needs Before Scaling?
Premature scaling is the most quoted response to why startups fail. This is based on the Startup Genome research of about 3200 high growth technology companies and the headline figure is quoted as either 70% or 74% depending on who is quoting it. At least one critic contends that the concept is circular, because failure was partly defined by the thing being measured.
So keep the number vague. You should hold onto the definition, because that aspect survives the argument. Premature scaling is when you grow one dimension before there is evidence to justify it. Hiring before there is work, spending before there is a repeatable channel, building features before anybody asked, raising before there is anything to pour the money into.
Which makes the useful question more focused than “should we scale”. It is: what would have to be true first.
The five dimensions, and usually which one is first
It’s not one thing: Premature scaling. The research broke it down by dimensions. Founders tend to over-extend a distinct dimension by temperament.
Staff. Hiring before there’s work defined. The tale is a new individual, who spends their first month inventing their own job.
Spend Increasing acquisition budget before anyone can justify which element of the budget is revenue-generating.
Product. Building for a roadmap, not a request. Often triggered by the launch of a competitor or one loud consumer.
Kind of business. Creating a second income line, a second sector, or a second price point before the first is established.
Funding. A story not a plan. Which turns a time problem into a time problem with a board.
Most companies are fine on four and stretched badly on one. It takes a twenty minute chat to figure out which one is yours and it impacts what you buy next.
The free test before you buy anything
There’s a very standard product-market fit benchmark out there. Ask the people who use your product how they would feel if they couldn’t use it anymore, and see what share say “very disappointed”. The often quoted threshold is about 40%.
It’s a standard not a law, the sample is your own consumers so it’s easy to flatter yourself, and it works better for software than services. Run it anyway. Costs one email. Tells you more about preparation than any deck.
If you’re well below, growing spend will create expensive churn. That’s not a consulting problem. It’s a product or positioning issue. The most common way startups spend a year is by getting growth help first.
The four things that have to be true before scaling
You can describe who it is for, carefully enough to identify twenty real companies or a certain kind of person.
One or more acquisition channels work over and over, not just one time. Repeatable means you can explain why it works, so you might do it on purpose again.
The unit economics are basically known. How much it costs to get a customer, how much they’re worth and how long before you break even. Pretty much close enough. Absent is not.
Delivery holds at double the volume. If it all depends on one individual being heroic, scaling turns an excellent firm into a stressful one.
Most founders can tick one or two off. That’s natural, and that’s the honest response to if you’re ready.
What startup consulting services really offer
The term includes more than people think, which is why engagements fall apart when no one says which bit is being bought.
Validation and Studies. Is the problem real? Who has it serious enough to pay? What do they do about it today?
Go-to-market & positioning. Who are you for and how will they hear about you. This is the one most typically skipped and most often the real roadblock.
Price. The fastest lever, and usually the one founders are most concerned about touching.
Business and financial model. What the statistics have to look like for this to function, what breaks first if they don’t.
Operating rhythm. The way it’s decided once a week when there are above 4 persons.
Startup business consulting is diagnosis and decision-making. It is not execution and if you confuse the two that is when budgets go down the drain.
What a consultant can’t do for you.
Worth telling bluntly, because the ones that don’t work out usually didn’t work out for this.
They can’t tell you what your customers are thinking. They can design the way you learn.
They cannot choose what you are not choosing. They can show the cost of not doing so.
They can’t manufacture demand that isn’t there. Better placement will sell it to nobody more efficiently if nobody wants it.
They can’t replace founder conviction. Companies wind up with a plan that nobody in the building believes because they outsource the thesis.
The good ones will inform you when the answer is you don’t need them now. That phrase is also a fair test to use on first call.
Startup consulting services are most worth at a decision point. As a standing arrangement nobody reviews, they are least worth.
Advice, execution or a hiring
Three different buys, commonly mistaken for each other.
Business advisory services tell you what to do and why. Short engagements, top people, the product is a decision not a deliverable.
Execution constructs and runs the thing. Longer, more hands, output is a shipping site, a functioning campaign, a loaded pipeline.
A hire offers you lasting context.” Costly early and worth it when work is continuous and not a question.
The common mistake is buying execution to answer a strategic question. You get the incorrect thing done perfectly, on time and on budget.
The converse mistake is cheaper but slower: buying advice over and over and never acting on it. Two strategy documents and no change shipping implies the money bought clarity you already had.
Fractional, project or retainer
Project. A query having a fixed answer. Right for validation, for pricing, or for a go-to-market plan.
Fractional. Senior for a part of a week, still going. When you need the skill all the time but not the paycheck.
Retainer. 2. Continued support with flexible scope. Dangerous before that, right as soon as you know what you need, because the scope extends to fill it.
Begin with a project. It’s a cheaper method to see if you can work effectively together on something with an end date than a twelve month commitment.
The signals you are scaling too early
Hiring to remedy an issue that no one has documented.
Increasing ad expenditure since the figure looked good without knowing what part of it worked.
Creating features based on the loudest client rather than the most representative one.
Raise because the round is there not because there is a plan for the money.
Building a second market before the first one is settled.
That’s the silent churn you haven’t measured.
Any one of them alone is survivable. Whatever the percentage, it was the trend the Startup Genome research was describing: three at once.
Startup Growth Consulting– When Does It Really Apply?
Growth work presumes the foundation is there. It’s about doing more of something that already works, but better.
So the question to ask before buying startup growth consulting is a simple one: what’s working today that we want more of? If the real response is “nothing consistently yet”, you need validation or positioning, not growth.
This is rarely volunteered by agencies because the bigger sale is growing retainers. That’s also why a lot of growth engagements underperform – they were bought a stage too early and measured against expectations the stage couldn’t sustain.
What it costs when it does go wrong
The charge is rarely the engagement cost. It’s about time.
A startup that scales a year early spends a year building on an assumption. The correction usually requires unraveling hires, contracts and product decisions that were made on the strength of it. None of that shows up as a line item.
The reverse error is genuine but cheaper. Waiting forever, validating forever, doing a sixth round of research because the fifth wasn’t conclusive. There comes a time when the only way to settle the lingering ambiguity is to do it and more analysis is just procrastination in a suit.
The approach to distinguish them is to put down what evidence might change your mind. If you can explain it, and you have not gathered it, validate it. If you cannot express it you are procrastinating.
Questions to ask before hiring anyone
What would make you tell us not to?
Specifically, who is doing the work? And how much of their week do we get?
Physically, what does the output look like at the end of the process?
How many hours per week is that and what do you require from us?
What if we do not agree with the recommendation?
The first inquiry is the most telling. If you can’t describe a situation in which you would not recommend your own service, you’re selling, not advising.
Give an example of a past engagement where the recommendation was unpleasant – name the engagement and what happened following. The answer tells you if they stay in the room when the advise is undesirable which is the only time advisory is worth paying for.
Another exercise is to properly vet a provider, and it is well worth doing before any of the foregoing.
The thirty day version, if you want to DIY
Most of the diagnostic is stuff a founder can undertake. The payoff for paying someone is usually quickness and lack of self-deception, not access to secret knowledge.
First week. Ten customer dialogs. Not a poll. Ask what they were doing before you existed and what almost prevented them from buying.
Week two. Ask the disappointed question to every single user of the product. Put the number down and don’t talk about it.
Week 3. Calculate the cost of acquiring your last ten clients and estimate their value. An approximation is OK; the difficulty is the absence.
Fourth week. Write the four preparedness statements and circle each one true, false, or unknown.
You will receive either a decision or a very short brief. Both are better than the place most organizations buy consulting from, which is a vague sensation that things could be doing better.
Business Advisory Services In Order
Order matters more than overall spend, as it does with most things at this level.
Validate the issue. 3. Cheapest, and it invalidates everything downstream if you get the answer wrong.
Position resolved. Who it’s for and why over the other choice.
Price it intentionally, not by comparison.
Find one station you can repeat. One.
Then scale that channel, and that channel only, until it breaks.
With business advice services sold as a package, these typically roll up into one engagement, which is great as long as somebody can still tell you what stage you are on and what the exit criteria are for it.
Founders that do this in order generally spend less overall because each stage makes the next brief shorter and the next supplier cheaper to direct.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are startup consulting services?
Help with the decisions a founder has to make before scaling: Is the problem real? Who is it for? What should I charge? Which channel should I use? What do the numbers have to look like? The outcome is a decision rather than a deliverable.
When to Hire a Consultant for a Startup?
When a decision is preventing development and you don’t have the evidence or the experience to make it swiftly. Not if you need greater production. That’s an execution or hiring problem.
What’s the difference between startup business consulting and an agency?
An agency does. Consulting figures out what needs to be done. Many of the problems brought to agencies are actually the second sort, and that’s why the campaign is not doing as well as it could.
What is startup growth consulting?
Scaling what’s already working. If nothing is consistently working yet, then the honest engagement is validation or positioning instead, and a good consultant will tell you so.
How long should you be engaged?
Begin with a fixed project, not a retainer. A query with an end date shows you whether the working relationship is any good, at a fraction of the commitment.
Can we do it ourselves?
The thinking, absolutely, quite often. Founders that do it themselves keep the thinking. Outside aid earns its money when you are too close to the difficulty, or when experience of having seen the pattern previously saves you two quarters.
What this means for you
Effort does not get rewarded by scale. This is a decision that only works out if a few particular facts are already true, and much of the cost of being incorrect is unnoticeable until the next year.
Before you bought something, write down what would need to be true before you scaled. If that list is small and you can prove it, scale. If it’s long, you’ve just written the brief.
Simplified Startup helps founders with validation, positioning, price and go-to-market, all in one engagement instead of four vendors. Book a free session and bring that list.
Simplified Startup